The Court of Justice of the EU on Thursday annulled the European Parliament’s
2021 decision to strip Catalan separatist lawmakers’ immunity, citing doubts
regarding the impartiality of the process through which the measure was adopted.
Following the illegal Catalan independence referendum in 2017, former regional
President Carles Puigdemont and separatist politicians Toni Comín and Clara
Ponsatí fled to Belgium. Spanish authorities eventually charged all three with
alleged offenses of insurgency and misappropriation of public funds, and issued
warrants for their arrest, but Belgian judges declined to extradite them.
The Catalan politicians’ ability to evade Spain’s efforts to detain them
appeared to be reinforced in 2019, when all three were elected to the European
Parliament and gained the right to claim immunity as lawmakers. Madrid pushed to
stop the MEPs-elect from being recognized by the Parliament, arguing their
election could only be certified if they returned to Spain and swore allegiance
to the constitution, but the separatists were ultimately admitted by the
legislature’s then-president, David Sassoli, in 2020.
Spain then petitioned the Parliament to lift the separatists’ immunity, and in
2021 a majority of lawmakers voted in favor of doing so. Although Puigdemont,
Comín and Ponsatí challenged that waiver, the EU’s General Court upheld it in
2023, weakening their ability to evade Madrid’s extradition requests.
But Thursday’s appeals ruling by the top court annuls the Parliament’s decision,
finding the institution failed to “ensure the impartiality” of the procedure to
waive the lawmakers’ immunity. The high court’s doubts regarding the neutrality
of the process focused on Spain’s far-right Vox party, which was involved in
filing the criminal case at the origin of Madrid’s extradition request.
The court found that the Parliament violated the principles of impartiality by
permitting former Bulgarian MEP Angel Dzhambazki, whose European Conservatives
and Reformists Group then included the Vox party, to serve as the rapporteur
overseeing Spain’s waiver request in the Legal Affairs Committee. EU law
establishes that examinations of petitions of this kind cannot be led by
lawmakers connected to the prosecution.
As additional evidence of Dzhambazki’s lack of impartiality, the ruling notes
that the Bulgarian lawmaker participated in a 2019 event titled “Catalonia is
Spain,” at which the Vox party’s secretary-general declared, “Long live Spain,
long live Europe and lock Puigdemont up!”
In addition to having its 2021 decision annulled, the Parliament is ordered to
pay the legal costs incurred by Puigdemont, Comín and Ponsatí in their initial
challenge before the EU’s General Court, and their appeal to the Court of
Justice. The ruling represents a stark rebuke of the Parliament and its handling
of the Catalan separatist saga. The Parliament declined POLITICO’s request for
comment.
Of the lawmakers involved in the case, only Comín remains a member of the EU
legislature. Ponsatí returned to Spain in 2023 and was briefly detained before
being released by authorities.
Puigdemont remains in Belgium, awaiting the implementation of a controversial
amnesty law passed by the Spanish parliament in 2024. The legislation’s
application has been halted by the courts, with the separatist leader
specifically blocked from benefiting from the law due to pending embezzlement
charges.
Spain’s Constitutional Court last week rejected a request to suspend
Puigdemont’s arrest warrant. The same body is expected to rule on whether he
should benefit from the amnesty bill later this year.
Sebastian Starcevic contributed to this report.
Tag - MEPs
BRUSSELS ― The EU’s conservatives are convening for the second time in a week as
they increase internal coordination after a tough first year of Ursula von der
Leyen’s second term at the head of the European Commission.
After last weekend’s meeting of European People’s Party leaders in Croatia, this
week sees EPP members of the European Parliament gather in Slovenia, where they
will discuss policy with the bloc’s commissioners in charge of defense and
regional development. The party has powerful national chiefs, including German
Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, but is up
against surging opposition figures across the political spectrum.
“Populists on the left and right oppose everything without proposing anything,”
said European People’s Party Vice Chair Romana Tomc in a statement. The party
“will discuss who we will work with to deliver real change in Europe.”
Von der Leyen has seen off four no-confidence votes since the start of her
second term on Dec. 1, 2024 while the EPP has been boosted since May by the
return of a German chancellor from its ranks. But the group’s traditional
Brussels allies from the center left and liberal center have distanced
themselves from some EPP policies, especially those supported by the far right
such as the rollback of EU green rules, including cuts to corporate
sustainability and deforestation legislation.
The Ljubljana meeting is another example of how Manfred Weber, chair of the EPP
and head of its European Parliament faction, is trying to tighten
decision-making and bring more central control over policy in the Commission,
the Parliament and the Council of the EU, which represents national governments,
according to two EPP officials. Weber wants to use the different iterations of
EPP gatherings to increase the number of touch points for center-right leaders
and senior EU officials to meet and coordinate policies ahead of big moments on
the calendar, they said.
Next week’s EU diplomacy is particularly intense, with a meeting of defense
ministers in Brussels on Wednesday, a summit of EU leaders in the Belgian
countryside on Thursday, and the Munich Security Conference, which brings
together some of the world’s most powerful decisionmakers, from Friday to
Sunday.
COMING TOGETHER
The EPP is well represented in Brussels, with von der Leyen and Parliament
President Roberta Metsola its two leading figures.
In addition to regular pre-summit gatherings, where EPP leaders meet on the
morning of European Councils, Weber has inaugurated annual meetings of national
chiefs, of which last weekend’s gathering in Zagreb was the most recent.
“The more coordination we can have between various groups of people, the
better,” said an EU official granted anonymity to speak freely, like others in
this story. “Because then you have the relationships and the format to stop the
wheels coming off completely.”
At informal dinners held on the Tuesday ahead of the Parliament’s plenary
session in Strasbourg, the EPP’s commissioners, among them von der Leyen, as
well as economy chief Valdis Dombrovskis and tech boss Henna Virkkunen, sit down
with Weber and his Parliament vice presidents.
These dinners “were set at the beginning of the term and structured in a way
that allowed [the party] to have greater influence on the work of the
Commission,” said an EPP official.
“The goal — I won’t hide it — is to know in advance the direction the Commission
is heading and to have an impact already at the preparatory stage, even before
proposals are formally presented,” they added.
IRONCLAD SECURITY
The summit of MEPs in the Slovene capital, which kicked off Wednesday and runs
until Friday, is aimed at what the organizers call “strategic planning.”
Party members also pointed to the increasingly important role of policy position
papers that the EPP now regularly publishes. | Marko Perkov/AFP via Getty Images
In Zagreb last weekend, leaders agreed to work on making the EU’s mutual-defense
clause operational, and tasked two national leaders, as yet unidentified, with
spelling out how to make it an ironclad security guarantee. It’s never been used
because NATO has a similar provision, but leaders are worried U.S. President
Donald Trump will make that obsolete.
Such moves highlight how the EPP is trying to influence wider EU policy and get
ahead of security or economic decisions taken by the Commission or by leaders,
where opinions from parties opposed to the center right have to be taken into
account.
Party members also pointed to the increasingly important role of policy position
papers that the EPP now regularly publishes, which give direction to the party’s
senior officials and leaders.
The push to water down planks of the Green Deal, as well as an ongoing
deregulation drive, both originated in policy papers drafted by the EPP
following coordination meetings, two party officials said.
In its 2024 manifesto the party called for the creation of a defense
commissioner role, which von der Leyen made a reality when she took office. The
party also called for deregulation and watering down the EU Green Deal, which
became a central part of von der Leyen’s policy agenda during her second
mandate.
Gerardo Fortuna contributed reporting.
BRUSSELS — Disgraced British politician Peter Mandelson is facing demands to be
stripped of his pension as a former European commissioner if investigators found
he broke EU rules over his contact with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
Mandelson served as a European commissioner between 2004 and 2008 and is now at
the center of a spiraling scandal in Britain. Newly released files showed how
Mandelson, who was a senior British minister at the time, helped provide
Epstein, then a financier, with information about a €500 billion bailout to save
the euro in 2010.
The European Commission is looking into whether Mandelson broke its rules, which
apply even after commissioners have left office, though ethics campaigners have
called for a full fraud inquiry by independent investigators. Mandelson should
lose the commissioner’s pension to which he is entitled if he’s found to have
breached the rules, the campaigners said.
“Given the severity of allegations concerning Peter Mandelson’s deplorable
relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, the European Commission and European
Anti-Fraud Office must pursue an immediate investigation to establish any
potential misconduct both during and beyond his tenure as European
Commissioner,” Nick Aiossa, director at Transparency International, a leading
anti-corruption campaign group, told POLITICO. “Should it do so, Mandelson must
be stripped of his Commissioner’s pension.”
Daniel Freund, a Green MEP from Germany, condemned the lack of action and
investigations against “the most powerful people on earth” over their links to
the disgraced financier. “That EU commissioners were somehow involved with this
universe is just outrageous,” he told POLITICO. “Taking away the pension would
be justified if he broke any EU rules.”
Mandelson, 72, was entitled to an inflation-linked pension reportedly worth
£31,000 a year when he turned 65 for his four years as a European commissioner.
This is on top of other any pensions from his time as an elected politician in
the U.K. and in other roles.
Mandelson did not immediately respond to a request for comment. He has
previously said he was wrong to have continued his association with Epstein and
apologized “unequivocally” to Epstein’s victims.
In a statement, the EU’s anti-fraud office, known as OLAF, said: “We cannot
provide details regarding cases which OLAF may or may not be treating. This is
to protect the confidentiality of any possible investigations and of possible
ensuing judicial proceedings, as well as to ensure respect for personal data and
procedural rights.”
In London, Britain’s Health Secretary Wes Streeting said Mandelson should lose
the severance payment he was entitled to when his career as U.K. ambassador to
the United States ended over the Epstein scandal. Speaking to Times Radio,
Streeting also suggested Mandelson could potentially be stripped of related
pension entitlements.
The opposition Reform UK party said Mandelson should lose the pension he’s
entitled to receive as a former government minister.
Noah Keate contributed to this report.
BRUSSELS — European lawmakers from three left-leaning parties said Wednesday the
EU should investigate TikTok over allegations of censorship in favor of the
right.
One of TikTok’s new owners as of late January is a Donald Trump ally, Oracle’s
Larry Ellison. Users say that since the change in ownership, the platform has
censored hot-button issues in favor of the president and his political camp,
according to reports — including limiting posts about the Epstein files and
protests against U.S. border agents in Minnesota.
TikTok said some users have experienced disruption due to technical issues.
On Wednesday the group of 32 lawmakers asked the European Commission, in charge
of enforcing the EU’s platform rules on TikTok to open another investigation
into the platform to verify if it is “causing a systemic risk” to freedom of
expression and civic discourse.
“Users have reported issues with uploading videos, reduced reach, and unusually
low view counts, for content that mention the words Epstein, ICE [U.S.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement] and Minnesota” and some of the signatories
“can personally attest that the same episodes — glitches and frozen videos” also
happened in Berlin and Brussels, the MEPs said.
A TikTok spokesperson said there are no platform rules against “sharing the name
‘Epstein’ in direct messages,” and that an issue experienced by some users was a
technical problem “with one of our safety systems incorrectly responding in some
instances.”
TikTok is already under investigation for breaching its obligations around
systemic risks under the Digital Services Act.
The 32 signatories are primarily MEPs from the Greens, but also from The Left
and the Socialists & Democrats.
The platform struck a deal in late January with a group of investors including
Oracle and Abu Dhabi’s MGX, ending a yearslong saga over the ownership of its
United States operations.
PARIS — French prosecutors on Tuesday recommended that a five-year electoral ban
on far-right leader Marine Le Pen should be confirmed — a move that, if accepted
by the court, would likely prevent her from running in next year’s presidential
election.
Le Pen’s far-right National Rally is comfortably ahead in polls ahead of the
first round of the 2027 election but she is currently looking unlikely to be
able to stand as the presidential candidate herself thanks to a five-year
election ban, imposed over her conviction last year for embezzling European
Parliament funds — a ban she is now appealing.
In that appeal proceeding on Tuesday, the prosecutors sought not only the
electoral prohibition but four years jail, with one served as a custodial
sentence.
In an unexpected twist, however, prosecutors did not insist that the ban should
be immediately implemented. This could offer her a theoretical long-shot back
into the race, but it appears legally complex and politically risky.
Le Pen herself did not signal any major shift in the case. In remarks to BFMTV,
Le Pen said the prosecution in the appeal was “following the path taken” during
the first trial.
The court is due to make a final decision on the appeal this summer.
When it came to her narrow route back to the presidential race, the prosecutors
said the court should not impose the five-year ban immediately because there was
insufficient proof that the three-time presidential candidate could commit
further crimes if she is not sanctioned immediately.
This means that, even if found guilty at appeal, Le Pen could still try to have
the penalty lifted by bringing the case before a supreme court.
The supreme court which would look into the case, the Cour de Cassation, said it
would examine the legal challenge and make a final ruling before the 2027
election “if possible.” That timing could be politically problematic for Le Pen,
if the supreme court does not come to a decision until shortly before the race.
Le Pen had said she would drop out of the running if her electoral ban was
upheld. It is unclear if a ban without immediate implementation, as sought by
the prosecutors, would now change her reasoning.
Le Pen has been increasingly expected to be replaced by her 30-year-old protégé
Jordan Bardella because of her legal woes. Although he originally triggered
doubts within his own political camp on his ability to stand the rigors of a
presidential election, he has surpassed Le Pen as France’s most popular
politician according to recent polling.
Le Pen has already run for president three times, making the runoff in the last
two elections and losing to Emmanuel Macron. The 2027 election is widely seen as
the best shot yet for a National Rally candidate to win and become the first
democratically elected far-right leader in France since World War II.
Le Pen has shifted her defense strategy since the start of her appeal trial,
with a partial acknowledgement that some wrongdoing may have been committed
unintentionally. The National Rally has described the case as politicized.
Le Pen and her co-defendants are accused of having embezzled funds from the
European Parliament by having party staff hired as parliamentary assistants,
while working solely on domestic affairs rather than legislative work.
Italian MEP Roberto Vannacci on Tuesday formally broke with Deputy Prime
Minister Matteo Salvini’s far-right League party, capping weeks of internal
turmoil and exposing a widening rift on Italy’s right.
“I’m chasing a dream, and I’m going far. National Future,” Vannacci, who was
Salvini’s deputy, wrote on X.
He confirmed plans to move ahead with a new political project to the right of
the League, called National Future. The split followed a League federal council
meeting and a late-night face-to-face between Salvini and Vannacci on Monday
that failed to heal the divide between League moderates, led by Salvini, and
Vannacci’s extremists.
Vannacci led a faction of the party that had openly challenged policies of the
governing coalition led by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, including its support
for Ukraine.
In his announcement, Vannacci drew a sharp ideological line, rejecting what he
called a diluted right. “My right is not an à la carte menu … and above all it’s
not moderate,” he wrote, describing it instead as “true, coherent, nationalist,
strong, proud, convinced, enthusiastic, pure and contagious.”
In response, Salvini wrote on X : “Angry? No, disappointed and bitter.”
The message was also circulated in the party’s internal WhatsApp channels to
confirm the break. The League leader stressed that the party had embraced
Vannacci when others shunned him, offering him broad electoral opportunities and
senior roles.
“Being part of a party, a community, a family means not only receiving but work,
sacrifice and above all loyalty,” Salvini wrote, adding that recent months had
been marked by “rows, problems, tension” and signs of potential splinter
movements.
The split raises fresh questions about Vannacci’s political future, after the
Patriots for Europe group in the European Parliament removed him from its ranks.
In a statement shared with POLITICO by League officials, the group said his
departure from the League party made his continued presence incompatible with
the group’s political structure, while stressing that cooperation with Salvini’s
League remains unchanged at European level.
It is also unclear how many lawmakers will follow Vannacci. All eyes are now on
several Italian MPs close to him — including Domenico Furgiuele, Rossano Sasso
and Edoardo Ziello.
PARIS — Anti-immigration MEP Sarah Knafo of the Reconquest party is set to
advance to the second round of the Paris mayoral election in what would be a
historic first for a far-right candidate, according to new polling shared with
POLITICO.
The survey from Cluster17, a prominent French pollster, shows Knafo, who
formally entered the race in January, winning 10 percent of the vote in the
municipal election next month.
The data suggests her campaign is building traction — a surprise in a city where
the far right has always struggled — as she was on course to win only 6 percent
in December.
Reconquest is the party founded by Knafo’s partner, maverick far-right
politician and commentator Ériz Zemmour, who came fourth in the first round of
the 2022 presidential election.
Candidates who meet the 10 percent support threshold in the first round on March
15 advance to the runoff and earn representation on the city council. As it
stands, that would see an unprecedented five-way race in the second round on
March 22.
Socialist candidate Emmanuel Grégoire leads the race with 33 percent of the
vote, according to the poll. He’s followed by Rachida Dati, the conservative
culture minister, at 26 percent. Centrist Pierre-Yves Bournazel scored 14
percent, while Sophia Chikirou of the hard-left France Unbowed drew 12 percent.
Knafo’s platform includes several radical proposals such as halving the number
of public workers in Paris and rowing back on some of current Mayor Anne
Hidalgo’s signature policies, including reducing the speed limit on the Paris
ring road. Hidalgo also banished cars from the banks of the Seine River, but
Knafo wants instead to build a two-story passageway on the banks, with cars
traveling underground and pedestrians above.
Grégoire and Dati are clear front-runners in the race, but both have incentives
to forge an alliance with candidates on their political extremes between the
first and second rounds.
Jean-Yves Dormagen, president and founder of Cluster17, warned that Dati is
“caught in a pincer movement” between Knafo to her right and Bournazel in the
center.
“Dati doesn’t have a good campaign dynamic,” Dormagen said.
Despite Grégoire facing a similar risk of being outflanked by Chikirou to his
left, the Socialist candidate’s strong polling with voters from multicultural
backgrounds — a “decisive group” in Paris — gives him a boost, the pollster
said.
“It’s a real problem for Sophia Chikirou,” said Dormagen.
BRUSSELS — The European Commission on Friday announced an investigation into
Slovakia over the dismantling of its whistleblower protection office.
In its latest rule-of-law spat with Bratislava, the EU executive criticized
leftist-populist leader Robert Fico for trying to replace the office with a new
institution whose leadership would be politically appointed.
“The Commission considers that this law breaches EU rules,” it wrote in an
official note on Friday.
Brussels’ move comes amid strong pressure from lawmakers and NGOs to act against
Fico’s crackdown against independent institutions and suspected fraud involving
EU farm funds.
Zuzana Dlugošová, the head of the whistleblower protection office, said that she
had repeatedly warned Slovak officials that the plans were in contradiction with
EU law.
“If expert feedback had been taken into account, Slovakia could have avoided EU
infringement proceedings. Still, we believe that this process itself can help
foster a more professional and substantive debate on how whistleblower
protection should be properly set up in Slovakia,” Dlugošová said.
Slovakia’s permanent representation in Brussels and interior ministry did not
immediately respond to POLITICO’s requests for comment.
Brussels has given Bratislava one month to respond to its queries before taking
further action — which could potentially include cutting EU payouts to Slovakia
after a multi-layered process.
Since returning to power in 2023 for a fourth term, Fico’s Smer party has taken
steps to dismantle anti-corruption institutions, including abolishing
the Special Prosecutor’s Office, which handled high-profile corruption cases,
and disbanding NAKA, an elite police unit tasked with fighting organized crime.
“The European Commission’s decision … sends a clear message: protecting
whistleblowers is not optional — it is a core obligation of every EU Member
State,” Czech MEP Tomáš Zdechovský said in written remarks to POLITICO.
Before launching the probe, the EU executive had pressed Slovakia to roll back
on its anti-democratic crackdown.
EU Budget Commissioner Piotr Serafin encouraged Fico not to dismantle the
whistleblower protection office during a meeting in Bratislava in December,
according to two Commission officials with knowledge of proceedings who were not
authorized to go on the record.
Nevertheless, in December 2025, the Slovak parliament pushed through a bill that
cut short the current director’s tenure and weakened protections for
whistleblowers. It was set to enter into force in on Jan. 1 but Slovakia’s top
court paused the disputed decision to review whether it complies with the
constitution.
German Green MEP Daniel Freund welcomed the Commission’s move but urged it to go
even further.
“The Commission needs to do more. Fico’s government has dismantled the special
prosecutor for corruption, has dismantled the national crime agency and has
changed the penal code to have hundreds of convicted corruption offenders walk
free,” Freund told POLITICO.
Slovakia is already subject to another infringement procedure, launched by the
Commission in November, over a reform that enshrines only two genders in the
constitution.
Listen on
* Spotify
* Apple Music
* Amazon Music
Europe is testing how far it’s willing to go — at home and abroad.
In this episode of EU Confidential, host Sarah Wheaton talks to Jonathan Haidt,
author of the best-selling “The Anxious Generation.” His research is inspiring
social media bans for kids in countries including France and Australia, even as
tech companies and some researchers strongly contest his conclusions. Alongside
him is MEP Veronika Cifrová Ostrihoňová and POLITICO tech reporter Eliza
Gkritsi, who is reporting on EU deliberations on protecting teens’ mental
health.
Later, Sarah is joined by POLITICO’s Nick Vinocur and trade reporter Camille
Gijs, who was on the ground in New Delhi for the signing of the EU–India trade
and defense agreement — dubbed by Ursula von der Leyen the “mother of all
deals.”
Roberto Vannacci, an MEP and former general, is preparing to launch his own
political party, which would formalize a break with Matteo Salvini’s League and
potentially reshape the Italian far right.
He announced the launch of the new party on Instagram on Wednesday. Vannacci had
already registered the name and logo of the movement, Futuro Nazionale (National
Future), on Jan. 24, according to trademark filings.
His new project is being described by Italian media as an attempt to build an
Italian version of the Alternative for Germany (AfD) party and create a new
force that would sit to the right of Salvini.
Vannacci, a polarizing figure whose nationalist and anti-immigration views have
sparked repeated controversy, is currently deputy secretary of the League. But
weeks of internal tensions have pushed relations within the party to breaking
point.
Salvini had been expected to meet his rebellious deputy for talks, but
Vannacci’s latest move appears to reduce the prospect of a reconciliation,
pushing the party closer to a possible split.
The former general rose to prominence in Italy thanks to his on-stage charisma
and his extreme views on the country’s past, with critics accusing him of
historical revisionism. He has described dictator Benito Mussolini as a
statesman and said that the March on Rome in 1922, when the fascist party took
power, “was not a coup, but nothing more than a street demonstration.”
The rollout of his new party has not been without hiccups, however.
The National Future’s logo immediately caused confusion. In a statement, the
right-wing think tank Nazione Futura (Future Nation) sought to distance itself
from Vannacci’s initiative, saying there were similarities between the names and
logos of the two groups. The think tank is led by Francesco Giubilei, a
prominent figure on the Italian right.
On the political stage, skepticism is also growing over whether Vannacci’s
project will take off.
League Senator Claudio Borghi told POLITICO he doubted the party would even
truly launch, noting that Vannacci had previously registered a symbol without
following through.
“I will stay with Salvini,” Borghi said, despite having voted for Vannacci to
become an MEP. He stressed that Vannacci’s election was driven by the League
leadership, which placed him as the first name on the party’s candidate list at
the European election.
Borghi described Vannacci as “an intelligent and loyal person” who is unlikely
to break away from the party. “I think Vannacci will remain loyal to the
League,” he said. “He has been voted by League electors.”
And even if a new party were to materialize, Borghi said, it would struggle to
gain traction. “The media will love it,” he added, “but it would get 1 percent.”