BERLIN — Far-right German politician Ringo Mühlmann has taken a noteworthy
interest in exposing information his political opponents say could be of great
interest to Russian intelligence.
Using the rights afforded to him as a lawmaker for the Alternative for Germany
(AfD) in the parliament of the eastern German state of Thuringia — where the AfD
is the strongest party — Mühlmann has repeatedly asked the regional government
to disclose intricate details on subjects such as local drone defenses and
Western arms transports to Ukraine.
“What information does the state government have about the extent of military
transit transports through Thuringia since 2022 (broken down by year, type of
transport [road, rail], number of transits, and known stops)?” Mühlmann asked in
writing in September.
One day in June, Mühlmann — who denies he is doing Russia’s bidding — filed
eight inquiries related to drones and the drone defense capabilities of the
region’s police, who are responsible for detecting and fending off drones deemed
a spy threat.
“What technical systems for drone defense are known to the Thuringian police
(e.g., jammers, net launchers, electromagnetic pulse devices), and to what
extent have these been tested for their usability in law enforcement?” Mühlmann
asked.
Such questions from AfD lawmakers on the state and federal parliaments have led
German centrists to accuse the far-right party’s lawmakers of using their seats
to try to expose sensitive information that Moscow could use in its war on
Ukraine and to help carry out its so-called “hybrid war” against Europe.
“One cannot help but get the impression that the AfD is working through a list
of tasks assigned to it by the Kremlin with its inquiries,” Thuringian Interior
Minister Georg Maier, a member of the center-left Social Democratic Party (SPD),
told German newspaper Handelsblatt.
“What struck me was an incredible interest in critical infrastructure and the
security authorities here in Thuringia, especially how they deal with hybrid
threats,” Maier subsequently told POLITICO. “Suddenly, geopolitical issues are
playing a role in their questions, while we in the Thuringian state parliament
are not responsible for foreign policy or defense policy.”
‘PERFIDIOUS’ INSINUATIONS
AfD leaders frequently take positions favorable to the Kremlin, favoring a
renewal of economic ties and gas imports and a cease of weapons aid for Ukraine.
Their political opponents, however, have frequently accused them of acting not
from conviction alone — but at the behest of Moscow. Greens lawmaker Irene
Mihalic, for instance, last month called the party Russian President Vladimir
Putin’s “trojan horse” in Germany.
AfD politicians deny allegations they are using their rising parliamentary power
both nationally and in Germany’s states to try to pass on sensitive information
to the Kremlin.
Tino Chrupalla, one of the AfD’s national leaders, strongly pushed back against
the allegations his party is attempting to reveal arms supply routes to benefit
the Kremlin.
“Citizens have legitimate fears about what they see and experience on the
highways every evening,” he said in a talk show last month when asked about
Mühlmann’s inquiries. “These are all legitimate questions from a member of
parliament who is concerned and who takes the concerns and needs of citizens
seriously. You are making insinuations, which is quite perfidious; you are
accusing us of things that you can never prove.”
Tino Chrupalla, one of the AfD’s national leaders, strongly pushed back against
the allegations his party is attempting to reveal arms supply routes to benefit
the Kremlin. | Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images
Mühlmann, a former police officer, speaking to POLITICO, denied that he’s
following an assignment list “in the direction of Russia.”
Government ministers, while obligated to answer each parliamentary inquiry, are
not obliged to reveal sensitive or classified information that could endanger
national security, Mühlmann also argued.
“It is not up to me to limit my questions, but up to the minister to provide the
answers,” he said. “If at some point such an answer poses a danger or leads to
espionage, then the espionage is not my fault, but the minister’s, because he
has disclosed information that he should not have disclosed.”
FLOOD OF PARLIAMENTARY QUESTIONS
Marc Henrichmann, a conservative lawmaker and the chairman of a special
committee in Germany’s Bundestag that oversees the country’s intelligence
services, said that while the government is not obliged to divulge classified or
highly sensitive information in its answers to parliamentary questions, Russian
intelligence services can still piece together valuable insights from the sheer
volume and variety of AfD inquiries.
“Apart from insignificant inquiries and sensitive inquiries, there is also a
huge gray area,” Henrichmann said. “And what I have regularly heard from various
ministries is that individual inquiries are not really the problem. But when you
look at these individual inquiries side by side, you get a picture, for example,
of travel routes, aid supplies, and military goods to or in the direction of
Ukraine.”
Henrichmann said AfD parliamentary questions in the Bundestag on subjects such
as authorities’ knowledge of Russian sabotage and hybrid activities in the
Baltic Sea region as well as of the poisoning of the late Russian opposition
leader Alexei Navalny had caught his attention and raised concerns.
“Apart from insignificant inquiries and sensitive inquiries, there is also a
huge gray area,” Marc Henrichmann said. | Niklas Graeber/picture alliance via
Getty Images
AfD factions in German state parliaments have submitted more than 7,000
security-related inquiries since the beginning of 2020, according to a data
analysis by Spiegel — more than any other party and about one-third of all
security-related inquiries combined.
In Thuringia — where state intelligence authorities have labelled the AfD an
extremist group — the party has submitted nearly 70 percent (1,206 out of 1,738)
of all questions filed this legislative period. In the Bundestag, the parties
parliamentary questions account for more than 60 percent of all inquiries (636
out of 1,052).
The AfD’s strategic use of parliamentary questions is nothing new, experts say.
Since entering the Bundestag in 2017, the party has deployed them to flood
ministries and to gather information on perceived political adversaries, experts
say
“From the outset, the AfD has used parliamentary questions to obstruct,
paralyze, and also to monitor political enemies,” said Anna-Sophie Heinze, a
researcher at the University of Trier.
With regard to the flood of inquiries related to national security, the question
of what is driving the AfD is largely irrelevant, Jakub Wondreys, a researcher
at the Technical University Dresden who studies the AfD’s Russia policy, said.
“It’s not impossible that they’re acting on behalf of Kremlin. It’s also
possible that they are acting on behalf of themselves, because, of course, they
are pro-Kremlin. But the end result is pretty much the same. These questions are
a potential threat to national security.”
Tag - Cybercrime
BERLIN — One of Hungary’s most outspoken critics in Brussels has filed a
criminal complaint against Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán following a
failed attempt to hack his email account using spyware in the run-up to the
European Parliament elections.
German Green MEP Daniel Freund and German NGO the Society for Civil Rights named
“Viktor Orbán and unknown” in the complaint, which was seen by POLITICO, and
requested that the state prosecutor in the western German city of Krefeld and
cyber crime authorities launch an investigation.
“There are indications that the Hungarian secret service is behind the attack,”
Freund and the NGO said in a joint statement on Wednesday.
The complaint gives details about an email that someone claiming to be a
Ukrainian student sent to Freund’s parliamentary email address at the end of May
2024. The message asked the MEP to write a short message in which he would share
his “beliefs concerning the accession of Ukraine to the European Union,” as well
as a link. Freund did not click on the link.
The complaint said that Parliament warned Freund that the link contained spyware
likely made by the Israeli company Candiru, which was blacklisted by the U.S.
government in 2021 for human rights violations.
“According to the EU Parliament’s IT experts, the Hungarian government could be
behind the eavesdropping on me,” Freund said in a statement. “This comes as no
surprise: Orbán despises democracy and the rule of law. If the suspicion is
confirmed, it would be an outrageous attack on the European Parliament.”
Freund and the NGO asked prosecutors to open an investigation to clarify “the
facts of the case” through investigative measures including the questioning of
witnesses and conducting an independent forensic analysis.
The Hungarian government had not responded to a request for comment at the time
of publication.
If a device is infected with spyware, attackers can access all stored data and
communications. They can also activate the camera and microphone to listen in on
conversations.
Freund has been one of the key players to have successfully advocated for EU
funds for Hungary to be frozen. He also led a push to suspend Hungary’s
presidency of the Council of the EU last year.
French prosecutors said Friday that foreign interference is behind a wave of
apparently provocative acts — from stunts targeting Muslims to antisemitic
graffiti — that have struck Paris in the last two years.
Pig heads were found outside nine mosques on Tuesday, shocking the Paris region.
“Several of the pig heads had the inscription ‘MACRON’ written in blue ink,” the
prosecutor’s office said earlier this week.
Prosecutors have not yet publicly named a state actor as being responsible for
the various incidents, but the cases echo tactics previously attributed to
Russian networks seeking to exploit social fractures in Europe.
Foreign interference is “something we must take into account, and that we do
take into account, since in making an assessment of this type of acts that have
taken place in the Paris area since October 2023, we have nine cases,” Paris
prosecutor Laure Beccuau told BFMTV on Friday.
“It started with the blue Stars of David,” Beccuau said, referring to an
incident that saw the symbols daubed on building walls in the French capitals’s
14th district in October 2023 — and was later linked to pro-Russian
interference.
“Then came the ‘red hands,’ then splashes of green paint,” she said about
attacks that targeted the Paris Holocaust memorial in 2024 and 2025.
Earlier this month, pro-Russian posters were discovered on several pillars of
the Arc de Triomphe, showing the image of a soldier with the caption, “Say thank
you to the victorious Soviet soldier.”
Beccuau said investigators have identified similar patterns in the modus
operandi of individuals of Eastern European origin arriving for a short period
of time in France to carry out these acts.
“Sometimes they take photos of what they have done, and send the photos beyond
the borders to sponsors,” she said. “Some of the sponsors have been identified …
so we are fully able to be convinced that these acts are operations of
interference.”
Since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine began in February 2022, French
authorities have accused Moscow of spreading disinformation and orchestrating
symbolic provocations designed to sow mistrust in institutions and deepen
religious or political tensions.
Clea Caulcutt contributed to this report.
Prosecutors in Italy opened an investigation on Wednesday into a pornographic
website that reportedly included images of female MPs and journalists, including
Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni.
The Italian leader said she was “disgusted” after learning that doctored images
of her and other women appeared on the adult content platform, and called for
those responsible to be punished “with the utmost firmness.”
The site had more than 700,000 subscribers before it was closed last week.
The photos were taken without consent from social media accounts, public sources
and OnlyFans accounts, then doctored to emphasize intimate body parts or portray
the women in sexual poses.
Posts elicited often sexist and sexually explicit comments from male users. One
victim told the news website Fanpage the site demanded up to €1,000 a month from
victims to take down the pictures.
Florence prosecutors opened the investigation after several center-left
politicians complained to the police department tackling cybercrime. Hundreds of
women have now filed reports.
Under prosecutors’ plans, the probe will become part of a massive investigation
into revenge porn sites, including a Facebook group called “Mia Moglie,” which
saw men sharing intimate images of their own wives and partners online. It was
deleted by Meta last week for “for violating our Adult Sexual Exploitation
policies.”
“I am disgusted by what has happened,” Meloni told Corriere della Sera last
week. “I want to extend my solidarity and support to all the women who have been
offended, insulted and violated.”
She added: “It is disheartening to note that in 2025, there are still those who
consider it normal and legitimate to trample on a woman’s dignity and target her
with sexist and vulgar insults, hiding behind anonymity or a keyboard.”
Senator Mara Carfagna, leader of the center-right We Moderates party, whose
pictures also appeared on the website, said it was “horrifying” and has proposed
legislation requiring platforms to register the real identity of users and
strengthen the copyright of images.
Italy introduced the crime of revenge porn — the sharing of sexually explicit
images or videos, which were intended to remain private — back in 2019.
Russian basketball player Daniil Kasatkin was arrested in France on a hacking
charge at the request of the United States.
U.S. authorities believe Kasatkin negotiated payoffs for a ransomware ring that
hacked around 900 companies and two federal government entities in the U.S.,
demanding money to end their attacks, according to a report from AFP. Kasatkin,
who was arrested on June 21, denies the allegations.
His lawyer, Frédéric Bélot, told POLITICO that Kasatkin is a “collateral victim
of that crime” because he bought a second-hand computer with malware.
“He’s not a computer guy,” Bélot said. “He didn’t notice any strange behavior on
the computer because he doesn’t know how computers work.”
A French court denied Kasatkin bail on Wednesday, and he remains in jail
awaiting formal extradition notification from U.S. authorities, according to
Bélot.
Kasatkin had traveled to France to visit Paris with his fiancée and was detained
shortly after arriving at the airport.
He played collegiate basketball briefly at Penn State, then four seasons for the
Moscow-based MBA-MAI team. Bélot said Kasatkin’s physical condition has
deteriorated in jail, which he argued is harming his athletic career.
Joshua Berlinger contributed to this report.
The International Criminal Court (ICC) said it was hit by a “sophisticated and
targeted” cyberattack as NATO leaders gathered in The Hague for a summit last
week.
The ICC, which is based in The Hague, said it detected the incident “late last
week” and had contained the threat. “A Court-wide impact analysis is being
carried out, and steps are already being taken to mitigate any effects of the
incident,” the court said in a statement on Monday.
The Hague was the scene of the NATO Summit early last week. Dutch cybersecurity
authorities reported a series of cyberattacks known as distributed
denial-of-service (DDoS) attacks against local governments and other
institutions in the run-up and during the summit. Those attacks, limited in
impact, were claimed by known pro-Russian hacktivist groups online.
A power outage also caused massive disruption to train traffic in the country
last Tuesday. Dutch authorities said they were investigating the incident and
the country’s justice minister said he couldn’t rule out sabotage as a possible
cause.
The ICC in 2023 also reported a hack of its computer systems it believed was an
attempt to spy on the institution.
The global tribunal has recently come under scrutiny after it issued arrest
warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his former defense
minister, Yoav Gallant, over Israel’s military campaign in Gaza.
The U.S. Trump administration has slapped sanctions on the court’s Chief
Prosecutor Karim Khan in response to the arrest warrants. Khan also lost access
to his email provided by Microsoft in May, in an incident that has galvanized a
political push in Europe to wean off American technology for critical
communications.
PARIS — French authorities have denied Telegram founder Pavel Durov’s request to
travel to the U.S. for “negotiations with investment funds.”
The Paris prosecutor’s office told POLITICO that it rendered its decision on May
12 “on the grounds that such a trip abroad did not appear imperative or
justified.”
Durov was arrested in August 2024 at a French airport and has been under strict
legal control since last September, when he was indicted on six charges related
to illicit activity on the messaging app he operates.
He is forbidden to leave France without authorization — which he obtained to
travel to Dubai from March 15 to April 7, the prosecutor’s office said.
Russian-born Durov is a citizen, among other countries, of France and the United
Arab Emirates.
Durov’s lawyers in France did not immediately respond to POLITICO’s request for
comment. POLITICO has also reached out to his U.S.-based spokesperson for
comment.
Durov has grown increasingly critical of French authorities since his arrest.
On Sunday, as voters headed to the polls for the Romanian presidential election
runoff, Durov alleged that the French government — including the head of
France’s foreign intelligence agency, Nicolas Lerner — asked him to ban
conservative voices on Telegram ahead of the vote.
Paris vehemently denied Durov’s claims.
Russian and Iranian agents are behind “state-sponsored terrorism” against
Europe, the European Union’s top diplomat said Wednesday, responding to
revelations that Russia was recruiting people in Europe to spread disinformation
and conduct sabotage and cyberattacks.
European public broadcasters revealed Tuesday that pro-Russia hacktivist groups
were actively approaching people on social media site Telegram to conduct
sabotage and vandalism and support disruptive operations across Europe.
Journalists saw and directly received requests to carry out various acts of
sabotage, including plastering the EU quarter with anti-NATO stickers and
collecting the email addresses of 30 Belgian journalists seen as sympathetic
toward the Ukrainians. Participants were promised payments in cryptocurrencies
in exchange for the support.
“This is the war that is going on in the shadows,” EU High Representative for
Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas told Belgian broadcaster VRT in
response.
Recent incidents across Europe range from cyberattacks and espionage to targeted
arson, undersea cable sabotage and GPS jamming.
These attacks “against us are on the rise,” Kallas said.
The EU and NATO have ramped up their defenses against such “hybrid threats” in
the past months. Kallas singled out Russia and Iran as countries particularly
active in Europe.
A potential cease-fire between Ukraine and Russia won’t stop these types of
attacks in Europe, security officials warned.
“This is the war that is going on in the shadows,” EU High Representative for
Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas said. | John Thys/Getty Images
NATO’s Deputy Assistant Secretary-General for Innovation, Hybrid and Cyber James
Appathurai told VRT that he was “absolutely convinced” that cyberattacks would
continue to take place even if Moscow and Kyiv can come to an agreement about
putting down their arms.
Adversaries “cannot attack us militarily and do not intend to do so. But they
are frustrated and want to execute their ambitions in other ways,”
Appathurai said.
Cybersecurity experts including the United Kingdom’s former cybersecurity chief
are pouring cold water over Elon Musk’s suggestion that a large-scale
cyberattack on his social media site X came from Ukraine.
Musk on Monday said X had been deluged by a “massive cyberattack” involving
“either a large, coordinated group and/or a country.” The tech mogul and close
ally of United States President Donald Trump later told the Fox Business channel
that “there was a massive cyberattack to try to bring down the X system, with IP
addresses originating in the Ukraine area.”
But cybersecurity experts were quick to push back.
“What Mr. Musk has said is wholly unconvincing based on the evidence so far.
It’s pretty much garbage,” Ciaran Martin, a former chief executive of the United
Kingdom’s cybersecurity agency, who now teaches at Oxford University, told the
BBC on Tuesday morning.
The cyberattack on X impacted users since at least Monday morning and
destabilized many features on the website, such as viewing posts and user
profiles. Musk’s statements and cybersecurity experts’ observations suggest it
was a so-called distributed-denial-of-service attack (DDoS), which involves
pointing an overwhelming amount of traffic at a website to bring it down.
In a DDoS attack, the origin of IP addresses is largely irrelevant: The attacks
come from networks of electronic devices spread across the world, called
“botnets,” that direct the traffic to a targeted website.
Martin said that could mean some of those devices were from Ukraine, but “some
of them will be from Russia, some will be from Britain, from the U.S., South
America, everywhere. It tells you absolutely nothing.”
Dmitry Budorin, founder of Ukrainian cybersecurity firm Hacken, said on X that
DDoS attacks “botnets use hijacked devices worldwide, and the IP addresses seen
in the attack traffic are just those of the infected machines, not the
masterminds.”
Reuters reported an industry source saying the amount of traffic coming from
Ukraine appeared “insignificant.”
A pro-Palestinian group called Dark Storm claimed responsibility for the attack
on its Telegram channel. Cybersecurity researchers at Check Point Research,
which has been tracking the group, told POLITICO the Dark Storm group had
appeared to show proof that it had carried out the attack — but a spokesperson
for Check Point warned that attribution “remains complex.”
The cyberattacks on Monday came after days of organized protests and vandalism
at industry sites of Musk’s car company Tesla, directly targeting the world’s
richest man’s business interests in protest of his role spearheading massive
cuts to government departments.
Musk has also clashed with Ukraine’s government in recent weeks, including in an
ongoing spat about Kyiv’s use of his satellite network Starlink.
Lukasz Olejnik, a cybersecurity consultant and visiting senior research fellow
at King’s College London, said “multiple scenarios should be considered” when
analyzing Musk’s response, “including a potential false-flag operation, perhaps
trying to blame Ukraine.”
“In realistic terms, such a DDoS should not become a world-impacting event. But
the figure of Musk and his importance in current U.S. politics changes the
outlook,” Olejnik said.
PARIS — French Foreign Affairs Minister Jean-Noël Barrot voiced his confusion
over reports that the United States’ Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has ordered
a halt of offensive cyber operations against Russia.
“I have a bit of trouble understanding [Hegseth’s decision],” Barrot told public
radio France Inter Monday. The French minister said European Union countries
“are constantly the targets” of Russian cyberattacks.
Cybersecurity publication The Record on Friday reported that Hegseth had ordered
U.S. Cyber Command to stand down from planning offensive cyber operations
against Russia. The report was confirmed by other publications shortly after.
Cyber Command is the U.S. Department of Defense’s section conducting
cyberattacks and cyberdefensive operations.
Hegseth’s move raised eyebrows in Europe, where Russia is seen as a main threat
in cyberspace together with China.
Both French diplomatic officials and President Emmanuel Macron have repeatedly
accused Russia of engaging in hybrid warfare against France through
cyberattacks. “Russia is attacking us on information, cyber,” Macron said last
month, claiming that Moscow was seeking to “destabilize our democracies.”
A report published on Feb. 24 by Viginum, the French digital interference
service, said France was “the subject of a particularly aggressive and
persistent targeting by Russian information threat actors.”