Turkey has claimed half of the Aegean Sea falls under its area of marine
influence, escalating a territorial spat with Greece over where to put ocean
conservation zones.
The move comes after Greece said it would create marine parks in waters Turkey
considers its own.
On Monday, Turkey submitted to UNESCO a so-called maritime spatial plan, an
official document which sets the marine areas where activities including
fishing, tourism and renewable energy projects can take place. It also underpins
the creation of marine protection zones.
Even though the spatial plan does not define the country’s exclusive economic
zone, the map prepared by Ankara University reflects several of Turkey’s
long-standing territorial claims, many of which conflict with those of
neighboring Greece.
Greek officials complained the map effectively splits the Aegean Sea in half,
claiming the maritime zones of numerous Greek islands into Turkey’s proposed
maritime jurisdiction.
“Ankara’s map is not based on any provision of international law and produces no
legal effect,” Deputy Foreign Minister Tasos Chatzivasileiou told Greek radio on
Tuesday. “It reflects the long-standing Turkish positions but has no legal
force. Greece will move [to respond] at all levels.”
The move comes a week after the Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis
announced that legal procedures for the creation of Greece’s first two marine
parks, a contentious issue with neighboring Turkey, will begin this month.
Speaking at the United Nations ocean summit in Nice, Mitsotakis said the two
marine parks will be established in the Ionian Sea and in the Southern Cyclades
region of the Aegean Sea as a first step.
The move comes a week after the Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis
announced that legal procedures for the creation of Greece’s first two marine
parks. | Dumitru Doru/EPA
Greece faced a fierce reaction from Turkey last year when it initially announced
plans to set aside some of the waters between the two countries for ecological
sustainability. Ankara is contesting the sovereignty of some of the maritime
territory involved.
The exact location of the maps has not been made available yet, but, according
to Greek officials, the Southern Cyclades park will not involve contested areas.
Turkish concerns are more likely to focus on the Dodecanese islands and nearby
islets, which were part of earlier proposals but are left out of the Greek
government’s current planning.
Turkey asserts that the Greek islands are not entitled to full maritime zones
beyond 6 nautical miles. Greece upholds the position that this is against
international maritime law.
In the Eastern Mediterranean, Turkey’s map extends to the boundaries outlined in
a Turkish-Libyan maritime memorandum signed in 2020, an agreement that Athens
rejects as illegal and invalid. It also highlights some areas licensed to the
Turkish Petroleum Corporation for exploration activities.
In April, Greece completed its national Maritime Spatial Plan and published the
official map, outlining its maritime zones in the Aegean and the Eastern
Mediterranean, after years of delays that drew rebuke from the European
Commission.
Ankara rejected the Greek plan, arguing that it infringes on Turkey’s claimed
maritime jurisdiction in both regions, and criticized what it described as
Greece’s unilateral approach.
Tag - Maritime spatial planning
NICE, France — An international agreement on protecting the world’s oceans could
soon enter into force as French President Emmanuel Macron announced Monday that
enough countries have “formally committed” to ratifying the so-called High Seas
Treaty.
“While the Earth is warming, the ocean is boiling,” Macron said. “Our scientists
are telling us things we could never have imagined: heat waves in the very heart
of our oceans. And as the sea rises, in addition to fire, submersion is on the
horizon.”
The ocean generates more than half of the planet’s oxygen and absorbs 30 percent
of all carbon dioxide emissions. But with marine and coastal ecosystems facing
multiple threats — including the impact of climate change as well as pressures
from fishing and pollution — that could all change. Ocean oxygen content is
decreasing globally, according to a 2024 UNESCO report, and ocean warming is
happening at an unprecedented and accelerating rate.
“The ocean is our greatest ally, whether you live here in Europe, or anywhere in
the world,” said European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. “But if we
neglect the ocean, if we treat it without respect, it will turn against us,” she
added, pointing to the “ever more violent storms [that] ravage our coasts.”
Macron and von der Leyen spoke at the third United Nations Conference on the
Oceans (UNOC) in Nice, France, where delegations from more than 120 countries,
including more than 50 heads of state and government, are gathered in an attempt
to resuscitate the world’s long-suffering oceans.
The High Seas Treaty — or the the Agreement on the Conservation and Sustainable
Use of Marine Biodiversity of Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ), as it’s
officially known — sets standards for the creation of marine protected areas in
international waters, among other measures. It can only be implemented once at
least 60 countries have officially ratified it.
The agreement will, supporters hope, go a long way toward protecting 30 percent
of the planet’s lands and seas by 2030 as foreseen in the COP15 biodiversity
agreement reached in December.
Thanks to 15 countries which have newly “formally committed to joining” — on top
of the 50 or so ratifications already submitted — the High Seas Treaty will soon
be implemented, Macron said Monday morning.
“So that’s a win,” he said.
OUR GREATEST ALLY
The French president was flanked by von der Leyen, Brazilian President Luiz
Inácio Lula da Silva, Secretary-General of the United Nations António Guterres
and Costa Rica President Rodrigo Chaves, who is cohosting the conference.
“The sea is our first ally against global warming ,” Macron said in his opening
speech.
“Today, we are inches away from the 60 signatures for ratification,” said von
der Leyen. “So to bring the High Seas Treaty to life, Europe will contribute €40
million to the Global Ocean Programme. So I ask you all today: Please speed up
ratification, because our ocean needs us to play [our] part.”
The EU ratified the treaty last month. Lula, in his own opening speech Monday,
announced that Brazil would also soon be ratifying the treaty.
Environmental groups are encouraged by Macron’s announcement, which follows
weeks of speculation over whether the 60-country threshold for ratification
would be reached in Nice.
“Countries have finally stopped dragging their feet and it is hoped we can now
move forward with protection of one of the most important areas for biodiversity
on Earth — the high seas,” said Catherine Weller, global policy director for
Fauna & Flora.
“We now need those countries that have committed to ratification to get the
final technicalities over the line — and then the real work needs to begin,” she
added.
Weller urged leaders to follow “best practices” in designing connected networks
of “high-quality, well-managed” marine protected areas. They should safeguard
the migratory routes of critically endangered species like whales and sharks,
for example.
ELEPHANT (NOT) IN THE ROOM
The United States is conspicuous in its absence from Nice, having decided to
skip the conference, as reported by POLITICO last week. A State Department
spokesperson said the conference is “at odds” with positions held by the current
U.S. administration.
The conference, which ends Friday, is an opportunity for countries to discuss
and present new agreements on topics from environmental financing and deep-sea
mining to illegal fishing and bottom-trawling.
The summit aims to promote enduring uses of ocean resources — one of 17
sustainable development goals held by the United Nations. But the Trump
administration has rejected those goals, calling them “inconsistent with U.S.
sovereignty.”
Macron took a dig at the absent delegation, flaunting a new scientific program
aimed at exploring the world’s oceans — the “Neptune Mission” — while the U.S.
schemes to send astronauts to plant its flag on Mars.
“Rather than rushing off to Mars, let’s already get to know our final frontier
and our best friend, the ocean,” said Macron.
The European Commission will propose a sweeping new law to manage the use of
Europe’s oceans, in a surprise announcement that was broad in scope but light on
detail and opens the way for years of lobbying over how to treat EU marine
resources.
An earlier draft of the European Ocean Pact, obtained by POLITICO, did not
mention the Ocean Act, and Thursday’s announcement of concrete legislation
caught many groups by surprise.
The Ocean Act, announced on Thursday by EU Oceans Commissioner Costas Kadis,
will update the Maritime Spatial Planning Directive, which governs the economic
use of EU waters. The new law would be introduced by 2027.
But Kadis said the new act would go well beyond the scope of the MSPD, providing
a framework to implement the wide-ranging goals of the new European Ocean Pact,
a policy promise of Commission President Ursula von der Leyen’s second term.
Those goals include cutting red tape, promoting sustainable aquaculture and
fishing, boosting ocean tourism, strengthening maritime defense and investing in
ocean science.
“The [Ocean] Act will ensure that existing targets linked to the ocean are
identifiable under one roof and will facilitate their coherent and effective
implementation, while at the same time decreasing administrative burden,” Kadis
said Thursday.
But the announcement was light on detail, opening the way for multiple policy
fights between environmental and commercial interest groups.
WHAT WE DO KNOW
The promised Ocean Act, contained within the broader Ocean Pact released
Thursday, will strengthen maritime spatial planning through “improved
cross-sectoral coordination at national level” and a more organized approach to
managing sea basins, the Commission said.
It will also provide a “single framework” to help implement the European Ocean
Pact, while also reducing administrative burden — including by cutting reporting
obligations for EU countries.
The European Ocean Pact does not promise new, concrete measures for designating
new marine protected areas or improving their management, instead pledging to
“work on the effective implementation and enforcement of existing EU
legislation.”
The same goes for bottom trawling in MPAs, the controversial practice of
dragging heavy fishing nets on the seafloor to scoop up fish living on or close
to the seabed.
In an attached annex, it does reiterate an “aspirational goal” of phasing out
bottom trawling in MPAs by 2030, previously announced in a 2023 EU Marine Action
Plan.
The European Ocean Pact does not promise new, concrete measures for designating
new marine protected areas or improving their management, instead pledging to
“work on the effective implementation and enforcement of existing EU
legislation.” | Sina Schuldt/Picture Alliance via Getty Images
The draft plan also includes a section on ocean defense and protection of
critical infrastructure, as well as sections on international ocean governance
and on protecting coastal communities from the effects of climate change.
The document teases the arrival of a new EU Coastal Communities Development and
Resilience Strategy by 2026.
REACTIONS POUR IN
Environmental groups have described the measures as a “mixed bag” and a “missed
opportunity.” Still, they see promise.
The Ocean Act is “promising & could pave the way for a healthy ocean,
but only if it’s bold & binding,” said the NGO Seas At Risk on social media.
“The Commission’s commitment to an Ocean Act is a strong signal — if it comes
with binding targets, it could finally deliver real ocean protection,” said WWF
Ocean Policy Manager Jacob Armstrong. “But while the direction is right, the Act
will need to clarify key areas — including how public funding will be secured to
make ocean protection a reality.”
Fishers, too, see an opportunity.
“It’s a good idea to — the way that I understand the Act — to reshape some of
the dysfunctional legislation that’s in place when it comes to marine protection
and marine spatial planning,” Esben Sverdrup, president of the European
Association of Fish Producers Organisations, told POLITICO.
“There’s also a lot of insecurity in my sector and fishing communities: What is
going to happen in the future? Where can we fish in the future? Will there be
windmill parks? Will they be built? What would be protected areas? What kind of
protection would be in those areas?
“We hope that the Ocean Pact and the Act will provide more stability in terms of
how we manage the oceans, and that’s fundamental for the future of fisheries.”
He said he hopes it will lead to “fewer but much better Protected Areas in the
marine environment.”
Isabelle Le Callennec, an EU lawmaker with the center-right European People’s
Party who sits on the fisheries committee, said the pact “promotes a balance
between the necessary protection of the environment and the requirements of
maintaining a healthy maritime economy.”
Other political groups were less immediately satisfied. The European
Parliament’s center-left Socialists and Democrats group said it would “fight to
turn [the act] into real action: to protect biodiversity, defend jobs, boost
marine renewables.”
“Research, money, ambition; everything the Commission announces here is badly
needed,” said Green MEP Bas Eickhout. “Yet I also expect clarity on what we will
no longer do. Intensive fishing in nature reserves, for example. Hard action is
unfortunately lacking.”
This story has been updated.