A PRINCIPLED ANARCHIST WHO FACED DEATH WITH BRAVERY, FUMIKO KANEKO IS A MODEL OF
UNWAVERING DEFIANCE IN THE FACE OF OVERWHELMING ODDS
~ Jay Arachnid ~
Fumiko Kaneko is not a well-known figure in Japanese history, primarily due to
her adherence to anarchism; she is also not a well-known figure in anarchist
history, primarily due to her adherence to the more nihilist tendency. Prison
Memoirs is her incomplete autobiography, requested by the presiding judge at her
trial for treason; he wanted to know what led to her thoroughgoing rejection,
not just of the judicial process, but of the entire Emperor System.
The result is a memoir of her formative years, starting out as a non-person in
the bureaucracy of the Meiji Period—her parents were not married at the time she
was born, and she was not officially registered as the daughter of her aunt
(then living in recently occupied Korea) until she was nine years old. The
physical and emotional abuse by her aunt and grandparents was accompanied by an
enforced penury that could be described as Dickensian. The oppression she felt
as a child was reinforced both inside and outside her home by her family’s
mistreatment of Koreans they encountered, as well the Japanese occupiers’
mistreatment of Korean people more generally.
I say her autobiography is incomplete because it’s only in the final thirty
pages or so that the exciting part starts, when, after a brief stint as a
devotee of The Salvation Army, she gets involved with Korean anarchists in
Tokyo. But the preceding two hundred-plus pages are a fascinating narrative of
class differences, poverty and middle-class pretension, the rigidly hierarchical
Emperor System, and how it all intertwines to crush the yearnings and desires of
a clearly intelligent child and young woman. She writes: “But all the while I
was leading this aimless, listless life, I never abandoned my true goals and
hopes. What were these? To read all kinds of books, to acquire all kinds of
knowledge, and to live life to the absolute fullest.”
Fumiko, however, is not crushed, merely bruised. Her experiences of poverty and
hierarchical oppression (as a female child, as a bastard, as a comrade of
Koreans) clearly primed her for an attraction to anarchist ideas. She says,
“Socialism did not have anything particularly new to teach me; however, it
provided me with the theory to verify what I already knew emotionally from my
own past… the feeling, almost as for a comrade, toward the poor dog my
grandparents kept; and the boundless sympathy I felt for all the oppressed,
maltreated, exploited Koreans I have not written about here but whom I saw while
at my grandmother’s – all were expressions of this. Socialist ideology merely
provided the flame that ignited this antagonism and this sympathy, long
smoldering in my heart.” A classic anarchist coming of age story, similar to so
many others (cf, Paul Goodman, Emma Goldman, and others).
Once she found her place among other like-minded individuals, she was able to
read everything she could get her hands on. She mentions the influences of
Bergson, and Hegel, but the books that had the greatest influence on her “were
those of the nihilists. It was at that time that I learned of people like
Stirner, Artsybashev, and Nietzsche.” A true rogue’s gallery! Is it any wonder
that she says later, “What is revolution, then, but the replacing of one power
with another?”
The memoirs end with the beginnings of her relationship with the Korean
anarchist-nihilist Pak Yeol, with whom she was brought to trial. Unfortunately,
for readers interested in the specifics of Fumiko’s political leanings, or the
Japanese anarchist movement of the 1920s more generally, there’s nothing in her
memoir about the trial, the absurdity of the charges, or the anti-Korean pogroms
that had taken place in the wake of the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923. Fumiko
and Pak had been arrested along with hundreds of other Korean and Japanese
radicals in the wake of the powerful tremblor.
Naturally they were found guilty of treason and sentenced to death. The
so-called mercy of the Emperor led to their sentence being commuted to life
imprisonment. Her defiance during the court proceedings—nicely recreated in the
film Anarchist From Colony—calls to mind other famous anarchists who defied
judges, like Louise Michel (“I have finished; if you are not cowards, kill me.”)
and Louis Lingg (“I despise your force-propped authority. Hang me for it!”).
This rejection and contempt continued when she received the letter of
commutation: she ripped it to shreds in front of her warders.
Fumiko Kaneko was found dead in her cell in 1926. She had written a nearly
700-page manuscript, but left no suicide note. And there was no autopsy. The
introduction to the English translation, written by Mikiso Hane, states
categorically that she hanged herself from a rope she made in the prison
workshop, but that seems like a convenient tale told by a historian nominated to
the National Council on the Humanities by the first President Bush. Regardless
of the truth, the fact remains that Fumiko Kaneko was an example of a principled
anarchist who faced death with bravery and deep contempt for the state and all
its institutions. Her story, both the Prison Memoirs and the larger context of
early 20th century Asian anarchism, deserves to be more widely known among
contemporary anarchists. Not as a footnote of defeat, but as a model of
unwavering defiance in the face of overwhelming odds.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prison Memoirs of a Japanese Woman, by Fumiko Kaneko. Detritus Books, 2025
The post Book review: Prison Memoirs of a Japanese Woman appeared first on
Freedom News.